Protecting history: Minidoka internment camp survivors opposed to wind project
Credit: Hannah Ashton | Times-News | magicvalley.com ~~
Translate: FROM English | TO English
Translate: FROM English | TO English
HUNT – The first thing Paul Tomita remembers is the dust.
Sucking it in, choking on it and struggling to breathe. Watching his mother’s futile attempts to plaster wet newspaper over holes in the walls, trying to protect her loved ones as they slept.
“I was essentially suffocating there,” Tomita, 83, said. “I was supposed to die there.”
Imprisoned by five miles of barbed wire fencing and eight watchtowers, all he could see was sagebrush and dirt.
In 1942, his family was forced onto a train and traveled from an assembly center in Puyallup, Washington, to the Minidoka War Relocation Center in Hunt. At the age of three, Tomita was considered a threat to the U.S. because of his physical appearance.
More than 13,000 Japanese Americans in total were imprisoned there until the camp closed on Oct. 23, 1945.
Since being released, Tomita has traveled back to southern Idaho multiple times to prevent people from forgetting.
“We consider that site, as crummy as it is, sacred to us,” Tomita said. “Because that is our history.”
Now he feels that sacred site is at risk because of the Lava Ridge Wind Project.
Just a few weeks ago, Tomita learned that Magic Valley Energy is planning to build an up to 400 turbine wind farm in south-central Idaho. Current plans put the closest turbine two miles from the internment camp, which is now called the Minidoka National Historic Site and ran by the National Park Service.
“It would absolutely ruin the atmosphere of desolation and despair,” said Mary Abo, another Minidoka survivor. “That’s part of the lesson.”
Abo and her family were sent from Alaska to the camp. For a long time Japanese Americans didn’t want to talk about that time in history because of the trauma, she said. Preserving the sites helps to reveal the whole history, good and bad.
Tomita, Abo, and other concerned individuals attended the two virtual public scoping meetings held by the Bureau of Land Management last week. The BLM manages the proposed project land.
Public scoping is one of the first steps in the environmental impact process that is required under US environmental law. Scoping is the part of the EIS process where the bureau accepts comments on what the public wants to see included in the impact statement.
The announcement of the project has felt quick to Abo. Survivors and descendants of survivors are scattered around the U.S., which makes communication difficult.
“I was shocked, and I felt like it was wool pulled over your eyes,” she said.
The original deadline for the scoping period was Sept. 20. Feeling this wasn’t enough time, Abo and others wrote to the BLM and asked for an extension. On Sept. 13, the BLM extended the deadline to Oct. 20.
BLM project manager, Kasey Prestwich, said he wants to remind people the process is in the early stages.
“Even though they may feel like a decision has been made or we are further along in the process than we are, we are in the beginning of the process,” Prestwich said.
The BLM has identified the historic site as a preliminary issue, he said. The agency will conduct visual simulations and map the historic footprint of the site.
Survivors like Tomita are worried that turbines might be placed on the historic footprint of the camp. The footprint includes land that is not part of the historic site today.
Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act also requires a review to take place. The act calls for federal agencies to consider project impacts on historic properties.
“Part of our consideration of those impacts is looking at the setting and the feeling that would be impacted,” Prestwich said.
Magic Valley Energy project manager Luke Papez said they understand the site is well-recognized and important.
“I am glad people have expressed their concerns so they can be addressed in the EIS process,” Papez said.
Groups created to remember the incarceration say they are going to fight the project.
“We are going to do everything that’s humanly possible,” said Bif Brigman a member of the Minidoka Pilgrimage Committee. “We will pursue legal means, we will pursue political means. We will do whatever it takes to get them to back off.”
Brigman has been a part of the committee for the past 15 years and is the spokesperson for comments regarding the wind project.
He attended his first pilgrimage in 2005 and found it to be a life-changing experience. The last in-person pilgrimage in 2019 had more than 300 participants.
“Our site can’t be moved,” he said. “The history of the site can’t be moved.”
Friends of Minidoka, a non-profit that works to educate the public about Japanese American incarceration, is also against the project.
Erin Shigaki’s father was born at the Minidoka center. Due to a lack of doctors, he was delivered by a horse veterinarian. If this was a beloved national park, a project of this size in the vision line wouldn’t be considered, she said.
“We’ve had to fight and fight to have this history recognized and I think this is one more battle, unfortunately.”
This article is the work of the source indicated. Any opinions expressed in it are not necessarily those of National Wind Watch.
The copyright of this article resides with the author or publisher indicated. As part of its noncommercial effort to present the environmental, social, scientific, and economic issues of large-scale wind power development to a global audience seeking such information, National Wind Watch endeavors to observe “fair use” as provided for in section 107 of U.S. Copyright Law and similar “fair dealing” provisions of the copyright laws of other nations. Send requests to excerpt, general inquiries, and comments via e-mail.
|Wind Watch relies entirely
on User Funding