Request for health assessment
Falmouth (Mass.) Board of Health
The Falmouth Board of Health requests that Mass DPH immediately initiate a health assessment of the impacts of the operation of wind turbines in Falmouth. This appeal is compelled by two years of consistent and persistent complaints of health impacts during turbine operation.
We realize that this is an atypical health assessment study. The suspected agent of harm is not a food borne, waterborne, or airborne contaminant. Yet, the Wind Turbine Health Impact Study recently completed by the State suggests certain elements of wind turbine operation propagate to health impacts potentially as harmful as those caused by organic agents.
To assist Mass DPH in the identification of health effects and potential study subjects, the Falmouth Board of Health held a hearing on May 24th, 2012, at which we accepted further testimony from those individuals in our community who believe they are experiencing negative health impacts from the operation of three turbines in Falmouth. We have attached a summary [below], received testimony, and a map of respondents. We are appealing to the Mass DPH to conduct this study due to its ability to collect and analyze confidential health information.
Due to the increasing intensity of the reported health impacts, the Board is considering emergency actions. To determine the appropriateness of such actions, the Board requests immediate guidance on interim measures to protect the health of affected individuals while the complete health assessment is being conducted.
We look to your Department, as that which holds the highest duty to protect the health of the citizens of the Commonwealth, to assist us in this matter. Accordingly, we request a meeting at the earliest possible time with you or your staff We are certain that once you have read the attached testimony that we received, you will appreciate the urgency and need for such a meeting. That meeting can be coordinated through our Health Agent, David Carignan.
Falmouth Board of Health
Gail Harkness, Chairman
Jared Goldstone
Stephen Rafferty
George Heufelder
John Waterbury
To:
Ms. Suzanne Condon
Associate Commissioner
Massachusetts Department of Public Health
250 Washington Street, 7th Floor
Boston, MA 02108
June 11, 2012
Cc:
Falmouth Board of Selectmen
Mr. Julian Suso, Falmouth Town Manager
The Honorable Therese Murray, The State Senate, Boston, Massachusetts
The Honorable David Vieira, Massachusetts House of Representatives
The Honorable Timothy Madden, Massachusetts House of Representatives
Download original document: “Falmouth Board of Health letter to Massachusetts Department of Public Health [1]”
Oral and written testimony on wind turbine effects were submitted to the Board at a public hearing on May 24th, 2012, and further written testimony was accepted during the following week (until May 31st, 2012). Additional complaint reporting has been ongoing since April 2011, and is summarized separately. The testimony from May 2012 represents 63 individuals, and includes 47 individuals with self-reported health effects. Only written testimony is included in the following analysis.
The submitted written testimony is included in this package of data, and summarized in the tables below. Table 1 describes the number and type of testimony submitted; Table 2 summarizes the health effects; and Table 3 defines the health effects categories. The summary data is derived from a spreadsheet analysis of the written testimony, also attached.
The major health effect reported was sleep deprivation (85%) with attendant stress (53%), mental health problems (45%), hearing problems (32%), cognitive difficulties (25%), and other effects, summarized in Table 2 below.
Table 1. Number and type of testimony submitted
| Total number of testimonies submitted | 58 |
| Testimonies not meeting criteria for hearing | 1 |
| Total number of valid testimonies | 57 |
| Number of people represented | 63 |
| Testimonies with health effects | 41 |
| People with health effects | 47 |
| Testimonies with no health effects | 15 |
| – People employed at Technology Park | 12 |
| – People who live near Wind 1, Wind 2 | 3 |
Table 2. Number and percent of people with health effects by specific category of health effect
| Category | Number (Percent) |
|---|---|
| Sleep deprivation/fatigue | 40 (85.1%) |
| Stress | 25 (53.2%) |
| Cognitive difficulty; Decreased memory, concentration | 12 (25.5%) |
| Hearing problems; Pressure, tinnitus, pain | 15 (31.9%) |
| Headache | 11 (23.4%) |
| Mental health problems; Depression, mood disorders, anxiety | 21 (44.7%) |
| Systemic symptoms; Increased BP, P, palpitations | 10 (21.3%) |
| Difficulty with spatial relationships; Vertigo, loss of balance | 6 (12.8%) |
| Eye problems | 3 (6.4%) |
| Difficult interpersonal relationships | 2 (4.3%) |
| Thoughts of or attempted suicide | 2 (4.3%) |
| Have symptoms; requested interview | 6 (12.8%) |
| Total number with health effects | 47 |
Table 3. Spreadsheet category definitions
Self-reported symptoms from attached testimony were categorized using the following definitions to produce Table 2.
| Category | Definitions |
|---|---|
| Effects | (yes/no) |
| Sleep | Disturbance, deprivation, waking up at night |
| Stress | Mentioned stress in dialog |
| Cognitive | Decreased memory, decreased concentration, confusion |
| Ear symptoms | Pressure, tinnitus, throbbing |
| Fatigue | Tiredness (combined with sleep) |
| Headache | Pressure in head, headache |
| Anxiety | (combined with mental health) |
| Spatial relationships | Clumsiness, vertigo, balance problems |
| Eye | Burning, dry |
| Mental health | Depression, mood disorders, (anxiety) |
| Inter-personal relationships (IPR) | Separation, difficulty with people |
| Suicide | Thoughts, attempted |
| Nausea | Vomiting (combined with systemic symptoms) |
| Better | Better when out of geographical area |
| Interview | Have health effects, requested DPH confidential interview |
| Other | Decreased property values, need to leave home, need to sleep in basement or elsewhere, inability to enjoy property |
Download original document: “Falmouth Board of Health – Health Effects of Wind Turbines – Hearing Summary [2]”
[3]Wind turbine complaints by location (click for larger size)
Falmouth (Mass.) Board of Health Turbine Hearing, May 24, 2012 [4]
Also see: Nina Pierpont interviews Falmouth, Mass., wind turbine syndrome victims – September 2011 [5]
URL to article: https://www.wind-watch.org/documents/request-for-health-assessment/
URLs in this post:
[1] Falmouth Board of Health letter to Massachusetts Department of Public Health: https://docs.wind-watch.org/Falmouth-BOH-to-DPH-6-11-12.pdf
[2] Falmouth Board of Health – Health Effects of Wind Turbines – Hearing Summary: https://docs.wind-watch.org/Falmouth-BOH-Health-Effects-wind-turbines-Testimony-summary-5-24-2012.pdf
[3] Image: https://docs.wind-watch.org/Falmouth-BOH-complaints-map.gif
[4] Falmouth (Mass.) Board of Health Turbine Hearing, May 24, 2012: http://www.wind-watch.org/documents/falmouth-mass-board-of-health-turbine-hearing-may-24-2012/
[5] Nina Pierpont interviews Falmouth, Mass., wind turbine syndrome victims – September 2011: http://www.wind-watch.org/documents/dr-nina-pierpont-interviews-falmouth-mass-wind-turbine-syndrome-victims/