September 11, 2012
Noise

Infrasound from wind turbines – letter from Malcolm Swinbanks

Swinbanks, Malcolm

In his 2006 Canadian paper relating to infrasound and wind turbines, Leventhall criticised Dr Nina Pierpont for having referred to the impulsive noise from wind-turbines as “infrasound”, arguing that the relevant paper that she had quoted by G.P. van den Berg did not relate to infrasound at all, but only to dBA levels.

In 2003 & 2004, G.P. van den Berg actually published two separate papers, both relating to the specific windfarm in Holland that he (van den Berg) had assessed. The first paper did indeed only relate to dBA levels, but the second paper referred explicitly to low-frequency and infrasound, and described how the turbine blade passing in front of the tower could generate extremely low frequency impulses. Van den Berg did not consider that this infrasound was audible, but there is no doubt that he fully acknowledged its presence.

This second paper was presented at the conference on Low Frequency Noise in Maastricht in August/September 2004. Dr H.G. Leventhall was one of the conference organisers, and subsequently edited the proceedings.

In 1989, NASA identified & reported that a windfarm in Hawaii, with modern-style upwind rotors, was generating impulsive infrasound & low frequency sound which they attributed to the effects of the rotor passing through wind-gradients and shadowing. They analysed the sound characteristics, and then simulated numerically how different wind-gradients could give rise to such effects.

I have myself analysed data from a windfarm in Michigan, which was generating unambiguous impulsive infrasound. It was possible to identify separate impulsive contributions from six different turbines at distances of 1500 feet to 1.2 miles. The maximum power spectral levels for the discrete frequencies associated with the harmonics of the impulses was 64dB SPL. But the overall rms sound power level was 77dB SPL, and the peak of the time waveforms of the impulses was 88-90dB. This indicates one of the major errors that has consistently been made in assessing infrasound from wind-turbines. Examining rms power spectrum peaks shows only 64dB, while comparing time domain impulsive peak levels shows 88-90dB. This represents ~25dB difference in the assessment of the infrasonic intensity.

I explicitly pointed out this feature at the Stratford Conference on Low-Frequency Noise in May 2012, and at the Internoise Conference in New York in August 2012.

I would comment that I first became aware of the physical effects of infrasound when working extensively on site with an industrial gas turbine in 1980. I identified specific aspects which were closely related to some symptoms of sea-sickness with which I was very familiar, being a keen offshore sailor. Thus I did not doubt that infrasound under some circumstances can cause adverse effects, and the relationship to sea-sickness implied that there was probably some interaction with the balance mechanisms of the inner ear. So the more recent work of Dr Nina Pierpont did not strike me as heresy – rather, it endorsed an opinion that I had formed from my own direct, first-hand experience in an entirely different context, almost 30 years earlier.

Sincerely, Malcolm Swinbanks

References:

(1) Infrasound from Wind Turbines – Fact, Fiction or Deception. [1] Geoff Leventhall. Canadian Acoustics Vol 34 No 2 (2006) p 29

(2) Effects of the wind profile at night on wind turbine sound. [2] G.P. van den Berg. Journal of Sound and Vibration Vol 277 (2004) p 955

(3) Do wind turbines produce significant low frequency sound levels? [3] G.P. van den Berg. 11th International Meeting on Low Frequency Noise and Its Control, Maastricht, 30 August–1 September 2004

(4) Noise Radiation Characteristics of the Westinghouse WWG-0600 [4] (600kW) Wind Turbine Generator. K.P. Shepherd, H.H. Hubbard, NASA TM101576 July 1989

URL to article:  https://www.wind-watch.org/documents/infrasound-from-wind-turbines-letter-from-malcolm-swinbanks/

URLs in this post:

[1] Infrasound from Wind Turbines – Fact, Fiction or Deception.: https://docs.wind-watch.org/Leventhall-Infrasound-WT-CanAcoustics.pdf

[2] Effects of the wind profile at night on wind turbine sound.: https://docs.wind-watch.org/vandenBerg_turbinesnight_JSV2004.pdf

[3] Do wind turbines produce significant low frequency sound levels?: https://docs.wind-watch.org/vandenBerg-lowfreqnoise.pdf

[4] Noise Radiation Characteristics of the Westinghouse WWG-0600: https://docs.wind-watch.org/Noise-Westinghouse-600kw-windturbine.pdf