January 18, 2013
Blogs, Minnesota

Bald eagle annual deaths as high as 14

January 16, 2013 | baldeaglesitings.blogspot.ca

United States Fish and Wildlife Service predicts that between 8 and 14 American bald eagles could be killed annually if New Era Wind Farm is built as currently designed. The outcome of USFWS’s eagle mortality models [1] are dramatically higher than one eagle every-other-year as predicted by New Era’s consultant Westwood Professional Services. 
 
In November 2012, New Era was the first wind facility in the nation to apply to the USFWS for an “Incidental Take Permit” to be allowed to kill bald eagles with their wind turbines without the danger of federal prosecution. Bald eagles are protected under the federal Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act. Without an ITP, killing an eagle is against federal law. The ITP process for New Era is not yet completed.

The eagle mortality rates were one part of extensive analysis and comments that USFWS provided in response to New Era’s updated Avian and Bat Protection Plan [2] (ABPP) required by the State of Minnesota. Overall, the USFWS found a number of problems with the ABPP methodology and conclusions. The 2010 avian study reported zero nests and no eagles flying in the wind project area; USFWS estimates the area bald eagle population at well over 400. Problems identified by USFWS included a warning about killing golden eagles, which also fly through the area. The Service made it clear that there is no possibility of obtaining an ITP for golden eagles in this area of the country, so that killing one would be a federally prosecutable offense.

The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources provided comments on the same ABPP [3]. The DNR raised concerns about Northern Harriers, Henslow Sparrow, bats and other wildlife potentially impacted by the project and the lack of data provided by New Era. Northern Harriers are listed as a bird of national concern by the USFWS and a Species of Greatest Conservation Need by DNR.

Goodhue County is located within the broad corridor of the Mississippi River Flyway. This is the largest migration route in North America. Millions of birds pass through and stop over this area on their annual spring and fall travels. The New Era ABPP shows a failure to perform avian migration field studies despite the project’s advanced stage in the State permitting process.  Bats are also high on the list of concerns expressed by USFWS and the MN DNR. Bats are a keystone species known to die in large numbers at wind facilities

Few wildlife impact studies have been done before, or after, the construction of industrial wind facilities in the United States. However, the studies that have been done suggest high mortality of birds and bats. Raptors, such a eagles, are known to be at high risk of being struck and killed by wind turbine blades. A study in SW Minnesota showed a 47% reduction in raptor numbers after construction of wind turbines. It is not clear how many died, and how many abandoned the area as no-longer-suitable habitat. Bats die both from blade strikes and barotrauma.

New Era Wind Farm is a 78 MW industrial facility proposed for central Goodhue County in southeastern Minnesota. The project became nationally infamous [4] under its previous owner, Texas billionaire T. Boone Pickens. During Pickens’ ownership the project was called AWA Goodhue and was wholely owned by his Dallas based Mesa Power. The lack of local public support and the high number of educated and concerned citizens has made this the most controversial wind project in Minnesota history. Peter Mastic, formerly the developer, purchased the wind project from Pickens last fall and changed the name to “New Era Wind Farm.”

The previous ABPP for this project was rejected [5] by the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission at a hearing on February 23, 2012. It is unclear when the MPUC may hold a hearing on the updated ABPP. Due to Minnesota State laws promoting industrial wind, this project is not required to produce an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) as required of other industries.

The Coalition for Sensible Siting [6] is proud of the extensive and important feedback citizens provided on the ABPP. The USFWS and the MN DNR provided excellent and thorough review and comment on the ABPP. Many concerns raised by citizens (below) where confirmed by USFWS and MN DNR.

The updated New Era Wind Farm Avian and Bat Protection Plan (4 parts):

ABPP [2]
Appendices A-P [7]
Exhibits 1-9 [8]
Exhibits 10-19 [9]

Citizen Comments on the ABPP:

No migration studies in the Mississippi Flyway – Mary Jo O’Rielly [10]
Bald Eagle nest missing from ABPP – Doug Sommers [11]
Failure to study owls – Kelly Norman [12]
Failure to study raptors – Kristi Rosenquist [13]

Eagles, Owls and site control – Rick Conrad [14]
Turbines closer than 2 miles from Bald Eagle nests – Ann Buck [15]
Northern Harriers at risk – Bill O’Reilly [16]
Telling residents how to farm and hunt is nonsense – Joe Hernke [17]
Turbines near conservation lands – Jon Stussy [18]
New Era lacks site control – Rochelle Nygaard [19]
New nest and important eagle use area – Connie Ludwig [20]
Misleading data and failure to perform required surveys – Barb Stussy [21]
Misrepresenting Important Eagle Use Areas – Bob Rosenquist [22]
Waterfowl migration missing – Scott Logan [23]
Turbines located on forest edges – Marilyn Jonas [14]
Raptor nests and territories missing from maps – Scott Logan [24]
Misrepresents eagles and fails to study other species – Mary Hartman [24]
Assessment of turbine distance misleading – Kristi Rosenquist [25]
Obligating local government and citizens without due process – Paul Reese [26]
Request the MPUC perform a site visit – Marie McNamara [27]
60 minute point counts lasted only 45 minutes – Scott Logan [28]
Northern Harrier and other hawk data missing – Erin Logan [29]
Failure to perform required field surveys – Sue Hinrichs [30]
Failure to avoid CRP and other conservation lands – Tom Gale [31]
Performing bat surveys with broken towers – Mary Hartman [32]
Eagle point counts from poor vantage point – Scott Husbyn [33]
Bat mortality at 7800 annually? – Mary Hartman [34]


URL to article:  https://www.wind-watch.org/news/2013/01/18/bald-eagle-annual-deaths-as-high-as-14/


URLs in this post:

[1] The outcome of USFWS’s eagle mortality models: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={63888D05-E3AA-4E9F-99F3-ACFFA0313200}&documentTitle=20131-82811-01&userType=public

[2] New Era’s updated Avian and Bat Protection Plan: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={06CF40E5-6EA0-4A8C-9DD1-2631B35BAD99}&documentTitle=201211-80312-02&userType=public

[3] comments on the same ABPP: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={5A54BEDE-EFDB-450D-94CC-97243DD44F40}&documentTitle=20131-82652-01&userType=public

[4] nationally infamous: http://baldeaglesitings.blogspot.com/2012/04/t-boone-pickens-confirms-he-lost-his-in.html

[5] previous ABPP for this project was rejected: http://baldeaglesitings.blogspot.com/2012/02/mn-public-utilities-commission-rejects.html

[6] The Coalition for Sensible Siting: http://www.coalitionforsensiblesiting.com/

[7] Appendices A-P: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={04EA83E7-18CF-4A4F-AE39-05D3BB7725C6}&documentTitle=201211-80312-03&userType=public

[8] Exhibits 1-9: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={7137F963-F445-4E6B-B0CC-3D9D8E990E36}&documentTitle=201211-80312-04&userType=public

[9] Exhibits 10-19: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={F37A77AD-54F1-46A2-8E4D-829417ACEA77}&documentTitle=201211-80312-05&userType=public

[10] No migration studies in the Mississippi Flyway – Mary Jo O’Rielly: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={71888743-C9FA-414D-9A8D-7751E2C044B1}&documentTitle=20131-82693-01&userType=public

[11] Bald Eagle nest missing from ABPP – Doug Sommers: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={9F093ED1-3A97-4494-85BF-3D020B6B89FF}&documentTitle=20131-82647-01&userType=public

[12] Failure to study owls – Kelly Norman: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={E17F0FB6-F96D-41A6-9EE5-37F7B7A05F6A}&documentTitle=20131-82676-01&userType=public

[13] Failure to study raptors – Kristi Rosenquist: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={E986C326-4BA8-457A-B39F-302AD7F28F63}&documentTitle=20131-82681-01&userType=public

[14] Eagles, Owls and site control – Rick Conrad: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={0FC6002F-FFD0-43F0-86B8-CCE76DFBB98D}&documentTitle=20131-82443-03&userType=public

[15] Turbines closer than 2 miles from Bald Eagle nests – Ann Buck: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={0EB884F4-2D94-4082-A7AB-EEF6408AEE24}&documentTitle=20131-82678-01&userType=public

[16] Northern Harriers at risk – Bill O’Reilly: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={851DAEE2-3FB2-4471-9E0C-46C07A0CD517}&documentTitle=20131-82675-01&userType=public

[17] Telling residents how to farm and hunt is nonsense – Joe Hernke: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={76BD431A-A50A-489C-AB76-2DF3FB992D17}&documentTitle=20131-82729-01&userType=public

[18] Turbines near conservation lands – Jon Stussy: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={DBEC4CC2-4968-45AF-B501-1565A0ADEA77}&documentTitle=20131-82633-01&userType=public

[19] New Era lacks site control – Rochelle Nygaard: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={967C7183-8D08-465F-B3F3-40C199293F48}&documentTitle=20131-82667-01&userType=public

[20] New nest and important eagle use area – Connie Ludwig: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={17613B7E-6F3D-48E4-A8DB-D76937492133}&documentTitle=20131-82636-01&userType=public

[21] Misleading data and failure to perform required surveys – Barb Stussy: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={1972705C-179F-41C3-A2D9-EE7018D7D3D4}&documentTitle=20131-82632-01&userType=public

[22] Misrepresenting Important Eagle Use Areas – Bob Rosenquist: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={FEFE6558-2594-4513-87E1-1D00123E516F}&documentTitle=20131-82635-01&userType=public

[23] Waterfowl migration missing – Scott Logan: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={018002FD-7281-4CBB-95E3-EDF0B3958B99}&documentTitle=20131-82683-01&userType=public

[24] Raptor nests and territories missing from maps – Scott Logan: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={1454CAD3-AEE0-40EE-8E78-1F00D62E6E92}&documentTitle=20131-82683-02&userType=public

[25] Assessment of turbine distance misleading – Kristi Rosenquist: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={2D3D83E0-4DD6-4A8E-842F-54233F4C2536}&documentTitle=20131-82735-01&userType=public

[26] Obligating local government and citizens without due process – Paul Reese: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={4D700BC9-E8A3-4A5C-9834-24CF167120CE}&documentTitle=20131-82720-01&userType=public

[27] Request the MPUC perform a site visit – Marie McNamara: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={0B0B1FBB-0475-4FC1-86AF-BC2E84391547}&documentTitle=20131-82731-01&userType=public

[28] 60 minute point counts lasted only 45 minutes – Scott Logan: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={9CF9A396-24C7-445C-BF5F-A4F5D784B095}&documentTitle=20131-82683-03&userType=public

[29] Northern Harrier and other hawk data missing – Erin Logan: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={C6A7DF8F-51A7-405D-922D-ABE7698679AF}&documentTitle=20131-82686-01&userType=public

[30] Failure to perform required field surveys – Sue Hinrichs: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={F39E696A-B938-4564-91DD-6B189E155ABC}&documentTitle=20131-82680-01&userType=public

[31] Failure to avoid CRP and other conservation lands – Tom Gale: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={50495A59-2B5F-49A3-9DF6-FE5BD7F03A29}&documentTitle=20131-82674-01&userType=public

[32] Performing bat surveys with broken towers – Mary Hartman: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={0AC72C4F-98C5-46E9-962A-F678E0698646}&documentTitle=20131-82679-01&userType=public

[33] Eagle point counts from poor vantage point – Scott Husbyn: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={C7ACAC41-A14E-4F8D-9C07-1C72188AF82D}&documentTitle=20131-82742-01&userType=public

[34] Bat mortality at 7800 annually? – Mary Hartman: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/edockets/searchDocuments.do?method=viewDocument&documentId={0597A566-07F4-4259-B5CA-C53C37DABA15}&documentTitle=20131-82819-03&userType=public