[ exact phrase in "" • results by date ]

[ Google-powered • results by relevance ]


News Home

Subscribe to RSS feed

Add NWW headlines to your site (click here)

Sign up for daily updates

Keep Wind Watch online and independent!

Donate $10

Donate $5

Selected Documents

All Documents

Research Links


Press Releases


Publications & Products

Photos & Graphics


Allied Groups

Audit finds FirstEnergy overpaid for renewable energy credits, passed on expenses to customers  

Credit:  By John Funk, The Plain Dealer | www.cleveland.com 17 August 2012 ~~

FirstEnergy Corp. has spent millions of dollars more than it should have since late 2009 to comply with state renewable-energy mandates, two independent audits have found.

And the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio has allowed the Akron-based company to pass those costs on to customers – with a 7 percent interest charge – over the next three years. The charge will amount to about $5 a month for the average customer.

The law requires that a percentage of the power every electric company sells to be generated with renewable technologies such as wind and solar. Companies can buy “renewable energy credits” – or RECS – instead of the power itself or pay the state a fine, called an “alternative compliance payment.”

The audits found that the Illuminating Co., Ohio Edison and Toledo Edison relied on FirstEnergy Solutions, an unregulated affiliate, to buy credits from people and organizations that generate renewable energy.

And FES paid up to 15 times more for credits than the three local companies would have spent had they just paid the fines, a management audit by Exeter Associates of Columbia, Md., found. In fact, the cost of the credits was higher than credits anywhere in the country, before or since, the audit found.

The auditors called FirstEnergy’s decisions “seriously flawed.” They recommended that the PUCO consider not allowing the companies to pass on the “excessive costs,” a move the company said it would challenge.

The company said it had no choice but to buy the credits.

“We bought the credits to comply with the law,” FirstEnergy spokesman Todd Schneider said. “If the credits are available, you have to buy them. The alternative compliance payments are available only if there is a shortfall, if you can’t buy the credits.”

Fines cannot be passed onto rate payers. Expenses for credits can. And have been.

Schneider said the company decided to spread out the costs over three years to lessen the effect on customers’ bills. And he added that comparing Ohio’s renewable energy credit costs in the first years of the state program with the cost of RECs in other states makes no sense. “RECs were new to Ohio,” he said.

The cost of the credits is already showing up on customers’ bills – in half-cent-per-kilowatt-hour increases that will add up over time. The average residential customer uses between 750 and 1,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity per month.

Although the PUCO has already approved the costs in its recent acceptance of a new FirstEnergy rate case, the audit report is sure to come up in appeals to that rate case decision due Friday.

“Renewable energy is a cost-competitive option, and yet FirstEnergy chose to over-charge their customers,” said Daniel Sawmiller, an analyst with the Sierra Club.

“The Sierra Club will be looking to the PUCO to ensure that these excessive payments make their way back into customers’ wallets and that FirstEnergy’s other companies, like FirstEnergy Solutions, are no longer able to benefit at the public’s expense.”

A companion financial audit conducted by Goldenberg Schneider LPA of Cincinnati examined the amount of money the companies spent – nearly $126 million between the last quarter of 2009 and Dec. 31, 2011.

That cost has been added to all customers’ bills, in the form of a “rider” on the rate every customer pays per kilowatt-hour used.

In the last three months of 2011, the most recent quarter the audit examined, Illuminating Co. customers were paying an extra 0.4699 cents per kilowatt-hour, the highest in the state. That’s a few dollars on a customer’s bill but millions of dollars for the companies.

The auditors compared that charge to the charges levied by other Ohio utilities to pay for renewable energy credits. FirstEnergy’s three companies were the highest.

Source:  By John Funk, The Plain Dealer | www.cleveland.com 17 August 2012

This article is the work of the source indicated. Any opinions expressed in it are not necessarily those of National Wind Watch.

The copyright of this article resides with the author or publisher indicated. As part of its noncommercial effort to present the environmental, social, scientific, and economic issues of large-scale wind power development to a global audience seeking such information, National Wind Watch endeavors to observe “fair use” as provided for in section 107 of U.S. Copyright Law and similar “fair dealing” provisions of the copyright laws of other nations. Send requests to excerpt, general inquiries, and comments via e-mail.

Wind Watch relies entirely
on User Funding
Donate $5 PayPal Donate


News Watch Home

Get the Facts Follow Wind Watch on Twitter

Wind Watch on Facebook


© National Wind Watch, Inc.
Use of copyrighted material adheres to Fair Use.
"Wind Watch" is a registered trademark.