June 20, 2012

FERC confirms ‘one-mile rule’ for wind energy generating facilities

by NAW Staff on Tuesday 19 June 2012 | North American Windpower | www.nawindpower.com 19 June 2012

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has confirmed that its regulations provide that, for the purposes of calculating a qualifying energy facility’s net capacity, generating facilities are considered together as a single qualifying facility if they are located within one mile of each other, use the same energy resource and are owned by the same persons or their affiliates, according to law firm Stoel Rives.

In recent years, landowners and energy purchasers have disputed whether the location of generating facilities more than one mile apart is a “safe harbor,” ensuring that the facilities will be treated as separate qualifying facilities, or is instead a rebuttable presumption that may be challenged.

In its order, issued this month, FERC reaffirmed that the one-mile separation standard provides a safe harbor for establishing separate qualifying facilities.

In this docket, a project developer’s self-certification of two wind generation facilities as separate qualifying facilities was challenged both by a local landowner and by Xcel Inc. Opponents claimed that the two facilities should be viewed as a single larger facility, notwithstanding their more-than-one-mile separation and that the separate certifications were not made in good faith.

While the two facilities were connected to a common substation, the generation equipment of each was separated by more than one mile from the generation equipment of the other. The landowner sought an evidentiary hearing on its challenge, which, if granted, would have substantially delayed the developer.

FERC affirmed an earlier ruling it made on March 15 in favor of the developer. In holdings that may be important to other qualifying facility developers, FERC held that Congress intended to encourage the development of co-generation and small power production to reduce U.S. dependence on fossil fuels by promoting increased energy efficiency.

FERC then held that its regulation defining generating facilities as separate qualifying facilities, if more than one mile apart, does not create a rebuttable presumption. Instead, the one-mile rule constitutes a safe harbor that the developer is entitled to rely on.

While the developer can rebut the one-mile presumption under certain circumstances to establish separate qualifying facilities that are less than one mile apart, the separate qualifying facility status of generating facilities more than one mile apart is fixed by FERC’s rule, according to Stoel Rives, which represented the developer in the FERC case.

FERC also affirmed that the one-mile separation rule applies to the separation between electrical generation equipment. FERC rejected claims that “collector” lines or common interconnection facilities constitute generation equipment for the purposes of measuring the one-mile separation.

Therefore, FERC concluded, the developer’s wind turbine separation governed, even though its two qualifying facilities had collector facilities located within one mile of each other and had common interconnection facilities.

URL to article:  https://www.wind-watch.org/news/2012/06/20/ferc-confirms-one-mile-rule-for-wind-energy-generating-facilities/